Hello John,
There are some aspects of the macrobiotic diet that are healthy, including the focus on eating more whole grains and green vegetables. However, this diet may not be right for you. Individual needs vary and there is no one perfect diet for everyone. Also of concern is that the macrobiotic diet tends to be low in protein, low in calories, and may not provide enough of certain nutrients, such as vitamin B12, vitamin D, and calcium, for good health.
You did not mention whether you were trying to lose weight. From your comments, it sounds as if you are not trying to lose weight. Assuming this is the case, it is clear that a strict macrobiotic diet is not providing enough calories and protein to keep your body weight where you want it.
Weight loss occurs when we eat less energy (calories) than we burn through our daily activities. Your weight loss is telling you that you are burning more calories than you are eating while following the macrobiotic diet.
As I mentioned, some features of the macrobiotic diet are positive, but there are no good, well-controlled studies that demonstrate that a macrobiotic diet is effective for treating or curing cancer. A few reports have compared the experience of cancer patients who have tried a macrobiotic diet with expected survival rates for their type and stage of cancer. Other studies, called case series, have discussed potential benefits in patients who’ve tried this diet.
These reports have suggested that a macrobiotic diet may have some health advantages, but again, it is important to note that these are not well-controlled studies. They cannot tell us conclusively if macrobiotics will improve cancer survival rates. Also, it’s good to be aware that all cancers are different and what diet is good for one type may not be the best choice for other types of cancer.
If you like the general idea of the macrobiotic diet, you can use that as the base of your eating pattern and modify it to better meet your calorie and protein needs. A typical macrobiotic diet usually is based around the following general guidelines:
50% to 60% Whole Grains
25% to 30% Vegetables (non-starchy)
5% to 10% Soup (broth-based)
5% to 10% Beans Sea Vegetables (such as sea weed)
One way to change this diet so that you get more protein and calories would be to decrease the amount of whole grains and increase the amount of beans. For example, you could aim to have 25% of your diet coming from whole grains and 25% coming from beans. This will increase protein plus give you a couple hundred additional calories each day.
You can make up the remaining calories and protein by adding in additional sources of lean protein, such as fish (wild caught if possible) and whole food soy products such as tofu, tempeh, and edamame, which are steamed soy beans, often served in the pod in Japanese restaurants. They can be purchased frozen in most grocery stores. You might try adding in some of the healthier, starchy vegetables, such as sweet potatoes, for additional calories.
I suggest adding in some healthy fat, such as nuts, seeds, and nut butters to round out and improve the macrobiotic diet for you. This will increase the calorie content and help halt your weight loss as well.
And don’t forget that you need to get plenty of calcium, vitamin B12, and vitamin D from other sources if you are going to cut out all animal products such as meat and dairy. Good sources of calcium include fortified soy milk; dark green leafy vegetables such as kale, chard, and collard greens; and beans. Good sources of vitamins B12 and D include fortified foods such as fortified soy milk and fortified cereals, breads, and other whole grains. For people who eat no animal products, taking a vitamin B12 supplement can fill in the gaps too.
If you are not taking a vitamin D supplement, you may want to add this in. I have a blog on this topic. In my blog, I discuss the relationship between vitamin D and cancer risk and survival; safe and appropriate levels of vitamin D to supplement; and who should NOT take extra vitamin D. Please read this carefully and talk to your doctor to let him or her know that you plan to take vitamin D.
In fact, you should let your doctor know about all supplements, herbs, and other over-the-counter products you are taking. This can help prevent dangerous interactions between your cancer treatments and these products.
To read my vitamin D blog, you can go to:
http://www.caring4cancer.com/suzannedixon/blogs/archive/2007/07/05/vitamin-d-wonder-nutrient.aspx.
Last but not least, be sure you enjoy eating and give yourself permission to enjoy “treat” foods. If your diet is very healthy most of the time, having an occasional piece of pizza or a piece of pie is not going to negatively impact your health. The most important thing is to keep your overall diet healthy and based around high quality food like fruit, vegetables, whole grains, and legumes.
Those occasional treats will give you a few extra calories which your body seems to need and will keep you sane. Remember, eating healthfully is a gift, not a punishment!
Nutritionist Suzanne